Thinking about how I want to derive noun incorporation in Emerald and Haneko: Haneko has a type 2 system, while Emerald has a type 3. The easiest answer would be to say that Proto-Pakaran had a type 3 (or type 4) system that degraded into a type 2 system in Haneko, but was preserved in Emerald: The problem with that explanation is that I've already established that Proto-Pakaran had no agreement, all Pakaran agreement affixes are independent developments. It's unheard of for a language to have productive type 3 incorporation with no agreement.
The answer I came up with is that Proto-Pakaran had several N->V derivational suffixes. The one I'll focus on is
*-b'u, which creates a transitive verb meaning "S removes the N of O":
*d'asib'u "decapitate"
*asudyb'u "flay"
*kygab'u "shave"
*alagab'u "cut off the hand" (the Pakarans had a practice of taking the severed hands of their enemies as trophies)
The salient feature of
*-b'u (and most of the other such suffixes) is that due to its semantics
it was mostly only used with body part nouns.
In Haneko, the suffixes were reanalyzed as verbs (
*-b'u becoming
-ma or
-mi, in a fashion that's somewhat unpredictable synchronically) and the nouns they attached to were reanalyzed as INs, but the semantic tendency to use them only with body part nouns hardened into a grammatical restriction. Hence, a type 2 NI system was born.
In Emerald, the same thing happened,
but without the restriction to body part terms. Thus, we get a type 3 NI system in Emerald.
Also, considering giving Emerald a permanent name: Suéri. Y/N?
Ahzoh wrote:I made reflexive patterns for Vrkhazhian, but they don't feel right...
Reflexive:
Infinitive - ʾaCCakīC
Past - nōkCōCaC / nakCūCCam
Past Prog. - yūkCōCaC / yūkCēCCam
Present - kūCCīC / kūCCīCam
Present Prog. - hakCūCīC / hakCūCCam
Future - ʾīkCaCeC / ʾīkCaCCam
Well, how are they derived from the non-reflexive forms?
Chagen wrote:I can't do the first one but...
Shame on you! Relative clause strategies I usually figure out before I even decide on basic clause constituent order.